There is a lot of buzz in the healthcare community about a newcomer to the accreditation process. For many years, the Joint Commission was the first choice for providing accreditation for hospitals in the US. But Norway-based Det Norske Veritas (DNV) is gaining ground, representing more than 350 hospitals and growing since 2008, when it received deeming authority. DNV is now certified through 2020.
DNV offers a different approach to deemed status and provides accreditation built on two components:
The University of Utah Health Care System, Salt Lake City, switched to DNV in 2013.
“We are committed to providing the best healthcare possible to our patients, and we felt DNV was the vehicle that would help us reach our goals as we continue to improve,” says Kathryn Adamson, MBA, RN, administrative director of perioperative and trauma services at the University of Utah Hospitals and Clinics.
“DNV focuses our efforts and allows us to be creative in developing our processes without penalty,” she says.
“What is the general climate when you are getting ready for a Joint Commission accreditation survey?” asks Adamson.
In her experience, she says, there’s a lot of fear. Nobody wants to talk to a surveyor. Nobody wants to do anything wrong, but still they expect to get caught at something. So there is an atmosphere of punitive thinking.
Everybody ramps up every 2 to 3 years for the survey, she says, but the bottom line is people are just trying to fix things for the survey, and the end result is no sustained improvements.
A DNV survey is totally different, says Adamson. It’s done yearly, and the emphasis is outcomes focused and organization driven. It’s an entirely different paradigm shift from gaining accreditation to constant improvement.
“Accreditation becomes an asset for quality, patient safety, customer satisfaction, and improvement instead of the burden of something more to do,” she says.
Unlike the Joint Commission, which rewrites its manual every 2 to 3 years, NIAHO is much more consistent in its standards, and changes are infrequent.
The standards for DNV are not just going back to the basics but focusing on the fundamentals rather than the extraordinary, she says.
Having been part of many Joint Commission surveys, Adamson notes, “we would always want to point out the most extraordinary thing we had done.”
But the DNV wants to hear about the basics, she says—“your basic structure, the basic things you do, and how you do them. DNV recognizes there are a lot of different ways to meet their requirements and that this is your program and you set it up.”
Also, the demeanor of DNV survey teams is different from that of the Joint Commission teams, she says. “There is no ‘gotcha’ attitude. Instead, it’s ‘we want to work with you; we are all in the same business and striving for the same thing.’”
A DNV survey team includes clinical surveyors, generalist surveyors, and physical environment/life safety specialist surveyors (sidebar, right).
In the three surveys she has participated in, Adamson says, the surveyors have had OR experience or have been associated with procedure areas. “The teams are qualified. They are approachable. They know my problems, and they ask about them,” she says. “They are there to help, not to hinder.”
DNV also tries to send the same people or at least part of the same team each year for the survey. Because of this, Adamson notes, they build trust and reliability, and they become partners, not adversaries.
Because a DNV team surveys every year, there is a gradual introduction of ISO 9001 standards for quality management systems, and there is no need for additional staff, says Adamson.
The basic premise of ISO 9001 involves:
“This is your quality management program designed by your facility. You have to understand what works and what doesn’t work for you, and you have to take the time to implement it the right way,” says Adamson.
There are three basic fundamentals of ISO 9001, termed the “Three Cs:”
Using these principles, Adamson says they improved their patient satisfaction from the 50th to the 84th percentile.
“We always have findings because we are not perfect,” says Adamson. All findings require corrective action plans, no matter how many findings. The surveyors prioritize the order in which an organization needs to address any given finding, which is done by the category of the nonconformities found.
Compliance corrective actions include:
“Our journey with DNV began with questions,” says Adamson. “As an organization, we asked:
Part of the culture change was engagement of the physicians. “Physicians are getting more heavily involved because much of our reimbursement depends on our outcomes,” Adamson notes. In addition, the employees wanted to get more involved and be a part of the change.
Patients’ expectations were also changing. The University of Utah Health Care System was the first to publish what patients had to say about their physicians on their website.
Changing from the Joint Commission to DNV was a tough decision, says Adamson. “We were going from something we grew up with and were comfortable with to the unknown.”
However, she says, they decided to make the change because they believed it would help them with their mission to provide the best healthcare possible for their patients. ✥
Adamson K. Joint Commission, CMS, and DNV-GL: Mastering standards and regulations for successful surveys. OR Manager Conference, 2016.